Sunday, June 15, 2008
Alright Twilight Fans...
I just finished "Eclipse", book 3 in Stephenie Meyer's Twilight series. I put a post about it on my personal blog and was surprised that people were either fans of Jacob or fans of Edward, having never discussed the books with anyone before. So now I'm really curious. Who is it for you? Jacob or Edward?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
14 comments:
I'm for Edward all the way - most of the third book I thought he was too good for Bella and I was quite annoyed with her for not seeing how good he was.
Edward, OF COURSE!! I cannot believe that there are Jacob fans. Now...don't get me wrong. I love Jacob and I really want him to be happy in his life. (I like that I'm talking like he's a real person.) But he was so manipulative in Eclipse...I just did not like it at all. And....come on...Edward is the best. I love that guy. (My husband knows.) Also as a random note, I thought it was interesting to see how you can totally tell that Jacob is just a teenager and Edward really is 100 years old in that book by the way they reacted in different situations. Anyway, I've only met one other Jacob fan..but if Bella ends up with Jacob in Breaking Dawn I will be very mad....very.
Jacob, Jacob, Jacob!! Edward is alright, but I'm all about Jacob. See, I will be mad if she ends up with Edward, but I'm sure that's how it will happen... Just like Rachel ends up with Ross, not Joey in Friends... (I'm still way bitter about that, in case you can't tell!)
I pretty much echo Tiffany perfectly. I love Edward too (and my husband also knows :) I too will be so mad if she ends up with Jacob blahhhhhhhhh.
100% Jacob as far as which guy for Bella. I like Edward and his personality I just don't like Edward and Bella together.
EDWARD
JACOB!!! She can have a real life with him! I was all edward till the 3rd book. Now im 100% jacob jacob jacob!
I already said this on your personal blog, but it's so interesting to see the different perspectives! Definitely Edward, I'm a hopeless romantic!
Jacob! Edward is annoyingly perfect.
Edward!! He's so dreamy...
EDWARD!!
Totally Edward!! I get frustrated with how Bella acts like her and Jacob are best friends. Edward was only gone for a couple months, thats not long enough to become that close! Jacob seems very immature! Go Edward!
I am torn! I love love Jacob. Edward is pretty desirable, too, though.
My main problem is with Bella. She seems more infatuated with Edward - I mean, I know this is a story but in real life who is THAT obsessed with anyone? That she would basically die to her family so that she could be with her crush. I am not saying she shouldn't do it, I just think she is so immature.
I also like Jacob more because Jacob = warmth, life, vitality. Edward = cold, stone, dead.
Thank you Amanda!! I totally, one hundred percent think that Bella is infatuated with Edward!!! Bella drives me nuts. I don't like her at all.
Post a Comment